Homemade Eatmore Bars
Homemade Eatmore Bars taste just like the classic Canadian chocolate bar. Chewy, toffee-like squares filled with oats, peanuts, and a hint of chocolate.
This post may contain affiliate links
It’s Christmas baking time!! Also known as the time of the year that we pull out all of our recipes for our favorite sweet treats and try to narrow down the list of what goes on the goody tray.
AKA the time of year we spend a whole week’s food budget on sugar, butter, chocolate, and nuts in one grocery trip. Or is that just me?
This year I am paring it way down and only making a short list of my family’s very favorite treats. Homemade Eatmore Bars made the list.
I made these chewy treats for the first time last year, and they were the only new treat that I repeated. And anything I try that gets made again must be really good, since my “to make” list always seems never-ending.
What are Eatmore Bars?
If you live in Canada, chances are you’ve had the chocolate bar (that’s candy bar to my South of the border readers) Eat-More. Hershey describes the Eat-More bar as having a “unique taste of chewy dark toffee, peanut and chocolate”.
Eatmore bars are a taste of my childhood. My mom used to buy them by the case at Costco.
This recipe tastes like an exact replica – they’re chewy, they’re peanutty and they’re a little chocolatey. And they have oats, which add texture and fiber (but not quite enough for me to consider them a healthy treat).
I never used to make these Eatmore bars myself because I’d always steal them from the treat tray made by Mr. Dreamboat’s cousin.
But since we’ve moved away I’ve had to become my family’s Eatmore supplier. Lucky for me, they’re super easy to make. Only five ingredients! And they’re no-bake!
How to Make Homemade Eatmore Bars
The only prep work involved is chopping the peanuts (you can use a super-handy nut chopper or your food processor (just make sure not to process them too much) to save time), boiling the corn syrup and peanut butter (less than 10 minutes), and stirring.
Then simply pour the mixture into a 9×13″ baking pan that has been lined with parchment paper, cover it with plastic, and move it to the fridge to set.
This truly is a dessert that anyone can manage. The recipe makes a big tray, but they’ll probably still disappear in no time!
Homemade Eatmore Bars Ingredients
The ingredient list to make these chewy bars is short, and all of the ingredients are common and easy to find. You might just have them in your pantry already!
- Unsalted dry-roasted peanuts
- Rolled oats – make sure to use gluten-free oats if you need your Eatmore bars to be gluten-free
- Smooth or crunchy peanut butter – since you’re using peanuts in this recipe too, it doesn’t really matter if the peanut butter you’re using has bits of peanut in it too.
- Golden corn syrup – or use light corn syrup if that’s what you happen to have on hand.
- Semi-sweet chocolate chips – or you could use semi-sweet or dark chocolate baking squares or bars. Make sure your chocolate chips are dairy-free if you need your recipe to be dairy-free and/or vegan.
Want more Chocolate Recipes?
Homemade Eatmore Bars Nutrition Notes
The nutrition information is based on a small, bite-sized square, which is how I like to cut up my Christmas treats. If you are going to cut yours into bigger pieces, be sure to adjust the nutrition info accordingly.
Homemade Eatmore Bars
Equipment
Ingredients
Instructions
- Cut a piece of parchment paper to fit inside the bottom of a 9×13" baking pan (do this by tracing around the bottom of the pan onto the parchment, then cutting it out). Place the parchment in the bottom of the pan and spray the sides of the pan with oil.
- Run 2 cups unsalted dry-roasted peanuts through a nut chopper, or pulse in a food processor and pulse until they are coarsely chopped. Alternatively, coarsely chop by hand. Pour into a large bowl and stir in 1 1/4 cup rolled oats. Set aside.
- Mix 1/2 cup smooth or crunchy peanut butter and 1 cup golden corn syrup together in a small saucepan. Heat over medium heat until the mixture begins to boil, about 8-10 minutes. Remove from heat and stir in 1 3/4 cup semi sweet chocolate chips until completely melted and incorporated.
- Pour the peanut butter mixture over the peanuts and oats. Stir until well mixed. Spread mixture into the prepared baking pan. Cover with plastic and refrigerate until set, 1-2 hours. Remove from fridge and keep at room temperature to soften for 10 minutes before cutting. Cut into squares. Bars will keep in an airtight container for several days at room temperature, or several months in the freezer.
Nutrition
Tried this recipe?
Please Consider Leaving a Review!
Don’t like using corn syrup. Any other suggestions?
If there’s a specific reason you avoid corn syrup, you might be able to use honey. I would decrease the amount, maybe to 1/2 a cup as it’s significantly sweeter, but that may affect the texture of the bars. Note that 1 cup of corn syrup contains 88g of sugar, while 1 cup of honey contains a whopping 278g of sugar. There is little evidence to say that the type of sugar in corn syrup (people are usually concerned about fructose, but the type of corn syrup we use at home is rarely the “high fructose corn syrup” that is generally used for industrial purposes) is more harmful than any other type of sugar, and that just eating too much sugar in general can cause health problems over time.
These are so good. Warning: It is very difficult to just eat one.
I totally agree!
Worked great!
Amazing! Followed the recipe exactly.
I have a corn allergy would golden sruyp work?
Yes, it will absolutely work in this recipe 🙂
I make a similar recipe without the rolled oats- much better and chewier; as well as more like Eatmore bars.
Hi Carissa. I made this recipe and had some trouble getting the nuts to incorporate. So I’m left with loose nuts everywhere! Could I heat it up again and try to compress it together again?
Help!
I have not experienced this issue, but I think it works be due to a heating issue. It could possibly be that the corn syrup heated too much, which might cause it too harden too much, in which case it would be difficult to save. It’s also possible that it might not have heated enough, in which case re-heating it very gently might save it. Try to heat it over low heat until it softens enough to mix, and try to incorporate the nuts, and press it into the pan.